All I really want here is your opinions, there is no wrong or right answer, only ones with little or no thought:
Here are a few questions for you to ponder:
1. if a Muslim exchange student wishes to pray to Mecca should he be allowed in a public school?
2. if a Protestant child wants to pray to Jesus Christ should he be forbidden?
3. is it fair to discipline a school child who aligns himself with Anton LaVey’s concept of Satanism and freely speaks of it on school grounds?
4. should teachers refrain from uttering words like Buddhism in their teachings of ancient Asia?
think about those for a second first individually then collectively
then answer before you read the next and final paragraph…
ok if you answered no, yes, yes, yes then you probably are 100% for segregation of church and state; if you answered yes, no, no, no then you probably are 100% against it. now if you answered differently from these 2 combinations you obviously have bias! just think!
Why should it matter if a student is muslim or christian? You don’t seem to understand that the first amendment means freedom of religion, not freedom to practice only christian religion.
As the supreme court has determined NUMEROUS times, any student can be allowed to initiate their own prayers at school. This does not violate the concept of the establishment clause of the First Amendment (that the state shall not establish a religion). The problem arises when the school or state initiates the religious activity.
As a result,
1. Yes the student should be allowed to do his/her prayer, it is his/her right to practice his/her religion
2. No, this child should not be forbidden from praying to Jesus
3. A child should not be disciplined for speaking about Anton Lavey any more than a Child speaking about any other religion. There would only be a problem if someone is trying to incite violence.
4. No teachers should not refrain from mentioning Buddhism in a class on ancient asia. The fact is that isn’t establishing religion, it is discussing the religion in the context of the history of the area. Just like you can’t discuss the middle ages without understanding the impact that christianity had. Otherwise students aren’t being taught the correct history of the world.
Also, it is not SEGREGATION of church and state, it is SEPARATION of church and state. The purpose is to not have the government establishing a religion and trying to make its citizens practice that one religion. A student initiating a prayer at school, regardless of religion has nothing to do with what the state wants and the Supereme Court has stated this time and time again. As a result, your final paragraph shows your lack of understanding of the First Amendment’s Establishment clause as you seem to misunderstand what separation of church and state is. It is unconstitutional for a TEACHER to initiate prayer. It is perfectly alright for a student to do so.